A Unforgettable Governors Island Proposal at Collective Retreats | NYC Proposal Photographer

As a NYC proposal photographer, I’ve captured hundreds (a few thousand) proposals across every corner of the city—but few spots rival the magic of Governors Island at sunset, where there are no crowds and no unobstructed views. For Dhruv’s surprise proposal at Collective Retreats, we planned every detail carefully to make sure this early October moment unfolded flawlessly against one of the most scenic backdrops in New York City.

Planning the Perfect Governors Island Proposal

Governors Island is unlike any other proposal location in NYC—it’s peaceful, scenic, and feels like a world away from the city, even though it’s just an 8-minute ferry ride from Lower Manhattan. Dhruv and I coordinated the timing down to the minute. They’d spend the day on the island at the retreat, and I would arrive to their private cabin just before they’d come back for dinner.

We chose Collective Retreats, the island’s beautiful glamping-style resort, for its private, relaxed setting and incredible views of the Statue of Liberty. After a quick walkthrough earlier in the week, we decided to capture the big moment at Outlook Hill, one of the island’s highest points with a 360° panoramic view of Manhattan, New Jersey, New York Harbor, and Lady Liberty herself.

Why Governors Island is a Hidden Gem for Proposals

For couples looking for something unique yet quintessentially New York, Governors Island offers it all—privacy, skyline views, and a touch of adventure. The ferry ride adds to the excitement, the lighting is incredible near golden hour, and there are endless opportunities for stunning photographs.

Whether you’re planning a sunset proposal at Collective Retreats, a romantic picnic by the harbor, or a panoramic moment atop Outlook Hill, this destination feels like your own private slice of New York City.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of  Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings. 

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Carl Schurz Park Summer Proposal

Carl Schurz Park is one of New York City’s most peaceful and scenic waterfront spots. With views of the East River, colorful summer flowers, and tree-lined paths, it offers a quiet and natural setting that feels miles away from the city’s busy streets.

For this proposal, the day couldn’t have been more perfect. The sun was out, and the trees were in full bloom. Adam chose a spot overlooking the water—simple, open, and surrounded by greenery. It was there that he got down on one knee.

The moment was calm and personal. After she said yes, the two took a walk through the garden areas and tree-covered paths, stopping for portraits among the blooming flowers.

Every photo from the day carried that warm summer color palette—bright greens, soft pinks, and the clear blue of the water in the distance. Carl Schurz Park’s mix of light, nature, and space made it an ideal setting for this kind of intimate moment.

Why Carl Schurz Park Is a Great Spot for Proposals

Carl Schurz Park offers a quieter, more relaxed alternative to some of Manhattan’s busier parks. Located along the East River, it features beautiful gardens, open lawns, and shaded walkways that make it an ideal spot for proposal photos.

During the summer, the flowers are in full bloom, and the views of the river add a peaceful, natural backdrop that photographs beautifully. For couples seeking a serene, scenic spot that retains a distinctly New York feel, Carl Schurz Park is a hidden gem.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of  Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings. 

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

A Sunny Afternoon Surprise Proposal at Pier 45

As a NYC proposal photographer, I’ve captured proposals all across the city—from iconic bridges to hidden gardens—but Pier 45 offers something refreshingly different. On this bright August afternoon, a couple chose this waterfront gem along the East River as the backdrop for their unforgettable surprise proposal. With the Manhattan Bridge towering overhead, the river sparkling in the midday sun, and even their dog by their side, the moment felt personal, joyful, and uniquely New York.

Why Pier 45 is Perfect for a Proposal
Pier 45, located in Manhattan’s Lower East Side, is part of the East River waterfront parks. It’s modern, accessible, and full of character—perfect for couples looking for a contemporary yet scenic proposal spot.

• Iconic Views: Pier 45 boasts sweeping views of the Manhattan and Brooklyn Bridges, as well as the Brooklyn waterfront.

• Unique Design: With curved wooden seating, elevated viewing platforms, and greenery built into its design, it provides versatile photo backdrops.

• Dog-Friendly: Since this couple brought their furry friend along, Pier 45’s open design made it an easy choice for a relaxed, pet-friendly proposal.

• Midday Magic: While many couples opt for sunset or golden hour, this session proves that with the right angles, even midday light can create stunning, vibrant images.

Capturing the Moment
For this proposal, I scouted the pier ahead of time to account for the strong summer light and busy waterfront foot traffic. As the couple arrived with their dog, I discreetly positioned myself near the curved benches where the big question would happen. The surprise unfolded seamlessly—complete with an excited pup bouncing around as she said “yes!”

After the proposal, we spent time capturing engagement photos along the pier’s walkways, using the bold lines of the Manhattan Bridge and the glittering water as a dramatic backdrop. Their dog stole a few frames, making the photos even more heartfelt and authentic.

Planning Your Pier 45 Proposal
If you’re considering proposing at Pier 45, here are a few tips:

• Opt for late morning or early afternoon when the bridge shadows create contrast and texture.

• Bring personal touches, like a pet or a planned excuse for being at the pier.

• Pair the moment with a nearby celebration—Pier 45 is just steps away from Chinatown, the Seaport, and Lower East Side dining options.

Whether you envision a midday waterfront proposal or something more traditional at sunset, having a professional NYC proposal photographer ensures every detail and emotion is beautifully documented.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of  Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings. 

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Daytime Surprise Proposal on Governors Island with Stunning Views

As a NYC surprise proposal photographer, I’ve documented countless unforgettable moments across the city—but a proposal on Governors Island always feels uniquely special. Just a short ferry ride from Lower Manhattan, Governors Island offers couples a mix of tranquility and sweeping skyline views, creating the perfect setting for a surprise proposal.

Why Governors Island Was Chosen for the Proposal

Governors Island has quickly become one of the most photogenic and romantic places to propose in New York City. On this summer afternoon, the location provided everything a couple could want:

• Unobstructed Views: The Manhattan skyline, Statue of Liberty, and New York Harbor all serve as dramatic backdrops.

• Spacious and Calm: Unlike Central Park or Brooklyn Bridge Park, Governors Island offers wide-open spaces with fewer crowds—ideal for a private and intimate proposal moment.

• Daytime Light: Even during the day, the bright summer sun reflected beautifully off the water and surrounding greenery, giving every photo a crisp, vibrant quality.

Capturing the Moment

The proposal took place atop Outlook Hill, where the skyline stretched across the horizon. From the build-up to the knee-drop moment, I captured every candid expression and emotion. After the big “yes,” we explored nearby paths, open fields, and waterfront spots for a mini engagement session, making the most of Governors Island’s variety of scenery.

Why Propose on Governors Island During the Day?

Many couples think about sunset or evening proposals, but daytime on Governors Island offers its own magic. The bright, natural light highlights every detail, while the views of the harbor and skyline are crystal clear. Plus, daytime proposals allow couples to celebrate afterward with activities on the island or a short ferry ride back to Manhattan for lunch, drinks, or more photos.

Planning Your Own Governors Island Proposal

If you’re considering popping the question on Governors Island, here are a few quick tips:

• Take the morning or early afternoon ferry to avoid crowds.

• Choose Outlook Hill or the waterfront esplanade for the best views.

• Plan a post-proposal activity, like biking around the island or a picnic on the lawn.

Whether it’s midday under a bright sky or sunset overlooking the harbor, Governors Island is one of NYC’s most versatile and romantic proposal locations. And with a professional NYC proposal photographer capturing the moment discreetly, you’ll have timeless memories to cherish forever.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

A Picture-Perfect Proposal at Pier 26 – NYC Surprise Proposal Photography

New York City is full of breathtaking locations for a surprise marriage proposal, and Pier 26 on Manhattan’s West Side is one of the best-kept secrets. With an unobstructed view of the Hudson River, stunning sunsets, and an open design, this location offers the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable engagement moment.

Recently, I had the pleasure of capturing Cody’s surprise proposal at Pier 26 on a warm and sunny afternoon. The clear blue sky and the panoramic view made for an incredible setting. Unlike many other spots in the city, Pier 26 offers an uninterrupted vista, ensuring that every moment is framed the open water and skyline.

Planning the Perfect Moment

Cody wanted his proposal to feel natural and intimate while still taking advantage of Pier 26’s expansive views. After some planning, we decided that he would lead his partner on a casual walk along the pier, pretending to take in the scenery before dropping to one knee at the perfect moment. This approach allowed for a genuine reaction while keeping the element of surprise intact.

Why Pier 26 is a Hidden Gem for Proposals

Pier 26 stands out as a top-tier NYC proposal location for several reasons:

• Unobstructed Views: Unlike many other waterfront locations, there are no buildings blocking the river, ensuring a clear, scenic backdrop.

• Modern and Minimalist Aesthetic: The pier’s sleek design complements any couple’s style, making it perfect for both casual and elegant proposal photos.

• Quiet Yet Accessible: Though it’s in Manhattan, Pier 26 tends to be less crowded than other popular engagement spots like Brooklyn Bridge Park or Central Park.

• Golden Hour Magic: Sunset proposals at Pier 26 are especially stunning, with the sun setting over the Hudson creating a dreamy glow.

Book Your NYC Proposal Photography Session

If you’re planning a surprise proposal in New York City, choosing the right location and photographer can make all the difference. I specialize in capturing the beauty of your once-in-a-lifetime moment, ensuring you have photos to cherish forever.

Let’s make your dream proposal a reality! Contact me today to start planning your unforgettable NYC engagement.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Spring Engagement Session at Gantry Plaza, Long Island City

As a NYC engagement photographer, few spots offer such a dramatic combination of city skyline and waterfront charm as Gantry Plaza State Park in Long Island City. On April 23rd, the park was alive with the fresh energy of spring — blooming trees, gentle breezes off the East River, and soft afternoon light reflecting on the water. It was the perfect setting for capturing a couple’s love story with the Manhattan skyline as a breathtaking backdrop.

Why Gantry Plaza is Perfect for Engagement Photos

Gantry Plaza is one of NYC’s hidden gems. Its wide piers and open spaces provide unobstructed views of the Empire State Building, One World Trade Center, and the East River, making every angle picture-perfect. The park’s industrial-chic gantries add character and a unique urban flair that balances beautifully with the natural beauty of the waterfront.

Couples choose Gantry Plaza for:

• Iconic skyline views — Manhattan’s towering buildings across the river make for cinematic shots.

• Waterfront ambiance — the gentle ripples of the East River add motion and tranquility.

• Open space and privacy — plenty of room to wander, laugh, and create candid moments without crowds.

Capturing the Moment

I love starting sessions here in the late afternoon, when the light softens and the skyline glows. On this day, the couple strolled along the pier, hand-in-hand, pausing to take in the view and laugh naturally. We moved between the gantries and the waterfront path, framing moments against the sparkling water and iconic skyline. By the time the sun was low, the golden light reflected off the river, creating those warm, cinematic images every couple dreams of.

Planning Your Gantry Plaza Engagement Session

If you’re thinking about Gantry Plaza for your engagement photos:

• Aim for late afternoon in spring or summer to catch golden hour over the skyline.

• Wear comfortable shoes for walking the piers and park paths.

• Scout the location with your photographer to maximize both scenic and intimate shots.
  
  

Whether you want sweeping skyline portraits or relaxed, candid moments by the water, hiring a professional NYC engagement photographer ensures every detail — light, angle, and timing — is captured beautifully.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer