A Unforgettable Governors Island Proposal at Collective Retreats | NYC Proposal Photographer

As a NYC proposal photographer, I’ve captured hundreds (a few thousand) proposals across every corner of the city—but few spots rival the magic of Governors Island at sunset, where there are no crowds and no unobstructed views. For Dhruv’s surprise proposal at Collective Retreats, we planned every detail carefully to make sure this early October moment unfolded flawlessly against one of the most scenic backdrops in New York City.

Planning the Perfect Governors Island Proposal

Governors Island is unlike any other proposal location in NYC—it’s peaceful, scenic, and feels like a world away from the city, even though it’s just an 8-minute ferry ride from Lower Manhattan. Dhruv and I coordinated the timing down to the minute. They’d spend the day on the island at the retreat, and I would arrive to their private cabin just before they’d come back for dinner.

We chose Collective Retreats, the island’s beautiful glamping-style resort, for its private, relaxed setting and incredible views of the Statue of Liberty. After a quick walkthrough earlier in the week, we decided to capture the big moment at Outlook Hill, one of the island’s highest points with a 360° panoramic view of Manhattan, New Jersey, New York Harbor, and Lady Liberty herself.

Why Governors Island is a Hidden Gem for Proposals

For couples looking for something unique yet quintessentially New York, Governors Island offers it all—privacy, skyline views, and a touch of adventure. The ferry ride adds to the excitement, the lighting is incredible near golden hour, and there are endless opportunities for stunning photographs.

Whether you’re planning a sunset proposal at Collective Retreats, a romantic picnic by the harbor, or a panoramic moment atop Outlook Hill, this destination feels like your own private slice of New York City.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of  Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings. 

LEARN MORE ABOUT HIRING A PROPOSAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN NYC

Daytime Surprise Proposal on Governors Island with Stunning Views

As a NYC surprise proposal photographer, I’ve documented countless unforgettable moments across the city—but a proposal on Governors Island always feels uniquely special. Just a short ferry ride from Lower Manhattan, Governors Island offers couples a mix of tranquility and sweeping skyline views, creating the perfect setting for a surprise proposal.

Why Governors Island Was Chosen for the Proposal

Governors Island has quickly become one of the most photogenic and romantic places to propose in New York City. On this summer afternoon, the location provided everything a couple could want:

• Unobstructed Views: The Manhattan skyline, Statue of Liberty, and New York Harbor all serve as dramatic backdrops.

• Spacious and Calm: Unlike Central Park or Brooklyn Bridge Park, Governors Island offers wide-open spaces with fewer crowds—ideal for a private and intimate proposal moment.

• Daytime Light: Even during the day, the bright summer sun reflected beautifully off the water and surrounding greenery, giving every photo a crisp, vibrant quality.

Capturing the Moment

The proposal took place atop Outlook Hill, where the skyline stretched across the horizon. From the build-up to the knee-drop moment, I captured every candid expression and emotion. After the big “yes,” we explored nearby paths, open fields, and waterfront spots for a mini engagement session, making the most of Governors Island’s variety of scenery.

Why Propose on Governors Island During the Day?

Many couples think about sunset or evening proposals, but daytime on Governors Island offers its own magic. The bright, natural light highlights every detail, while the views of the harbor and skyline are crystal clear. Plus, daytime proposals allow couples to celebrate afterward with activities on the island or a short ferry ride back to Manhattan for lunch, drinks, or more photos.

Planning Your Own Governors Island Proposal

If you’re considering popping the question on Governors Island, here are a few quick tips:

• Take the morning or early afternoon ferry to avoid crowds.

• Choose Outlook Hill or the waterfront esplanade for the best views.

• Plan a post-proposal activity, like biking around the island or a picnic on the lawn.

Whether it’s midday under a bright sky or sunset overlooking the harbor, Governors Island is one of NYC’s most versatile and romantic proposal locations. And with a professional NYC proposal photographer capturing the moment discreetly, you’ll have timeless memories to cherish forever.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

A Perfect NYC Proposal Location: Outlook Hill, Governors Island

Sunset Surprise Proposal on Governors Island’s Outlook Hill with the Manhattan Skyline

Governors Island is one of the city’s hidden gems—just a short ferry ride from Lower Manhattan, yet it feels worlds away. Outlook Hill, the island’s highest point, offers 360-degree views of the harbor, the Statue of Liberty, and of course, the Manhattan skyline. For Sid, it was the ideal setting to propose: romantic, peaceful, and visually stunning.

As a seasoned NYC proposal photographer, I always scout locations in advance and plan around lighting conditions and crowds. For this proposal, the timing was everything. Sid planned a whole day on the island with massages at the spa and a fantastic afternoon adventure ending atop Outlook Hill with the Manhattan skyline behind them.

Why Governors Island is Ideal for NYC Proposals

Unlike many popular proposal spots in NYC, Governors Island offers a calm, crowd-free environment—especially during sunset hours. Its unique mix of natural beauty and sweeping city views makes it perfect for couples looking for a peaceful, scenic proposal experience.

Whether you're planning to propose on Governors Island or another iconic NYC location, having a professional proposal photographer ensures the moment is preserved beautifully and discreetly. From candid emotion to scenic portraits, every element of Sid’s proposal came together flawlessly—and I was honored to be there to document it.

Planning a Governors Island Proposal?

If you're considering popping the question on Governors Island, especially at Outlook Hill, let’s talk! I’ll help you plan the timing, navigate the best light, and capture your once-in-a-lifetime moment against one of the most stunning views in New York City.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

Propose with a View: Governors Island, A Dream Proposal Spot in NYC

How to Hire a Photographer for Your Governors Island Proposal in NYC

Planning to pop the question on Governors Island? - Congratulations! But to truly capture the magic of the moment, hiring the right NYC proposal photographer is essential. You want someone who has previously planned a proposal for the island, and understands the logistics involved. Here's everything you need to know when booking with us for your Governors Island proposal.

• Consider a photographer who offers proposal planning support - we can guide you through each stage. From planning (date, time, exact location) and logistics (getting your partner there, ferry times), location recommendations (places with a view and privacy - no crowds), discrete photography until the big moment and a mini engagement session with posed photos post proposal.

• Choose a photographer who knows the island - with so many locations to choose from, getting it right is key! We have experience shooting at locations like Picnic Point, Outlook Hill and more!

Finding a Unique Proposal Spots for Every Style

Governors Island offers several romantic locations perfect for a proposal, including Picnic Point with its harbor views, The Hills for dramatic views, and Parade Ground for a large, open setting with the Lower Manhattan skyline. Colonels Row, with its trees and historic buildings, also provides a refined atmosphere

• Picnic Point - Located on the southern tip of the island, Picnic Point offers spectacular views of the Statue of Liberty and New York Harbor. It's ideal for a more relaxed, private proposal.

• The Hills - These elevated areas provide stunning views of the surrounding area, making for a dramatic and memorable proposal backdrop.

• Parade Ground - A large, expansive lawn near the waterfront, the Parade Ground offers the Lower Manhattan skyline as a backdrop. It's suitable for a larger proposal or if you're looking for a more open space.

• Colonels Row - Enveloped by trees and landmarked buildings, Colonels Row offers a refined and elegant atmosphere.

Things To Consider When Taking the Ferry

To take the ferry to Governors Island, consider purchasing tickets online in advance, especially for weekend trips when the island is at its’ busiest, and be prepared to arrive early. Ferries depart from Lower Manhattan and, on weekends, from Brooklyn.

Governors Island Ferry Information

• Purchase tickets online in advance, especially for weekend trips, as they tend to sell out. 

• Round-trip tickets are generally $4, but ferries departing before noon on Saturdays and Sundays are free. 

• Children under 12 ride free on all ferries. 

• Check the Governors Island website for the most up-to-date schedule

• The ferry ride to Governors Island is a short 10-15 minute trip. 

Why Governors Island is Perfect for Your NYC Proposal

• Unmatched Scenic Views - One of the top reasons couples choose Governors Island for their proposal is the panoramic, unobstructed views of the New York Harbor, Statue of Liberty, and the Manhattan skyline.

• A destination - Plan the day and make it an activity! - “Let’s rent bikes on Governors Island. I heard it’s fun and something different to do!” - Bike Rentals: Remember that Governors Island is a walking and cycling island, so you can explore the island by bike if you prefer!

• A Peaceful Escape - Despite being just minutes from Lower Manhattan, Governors Island feels like a tranquil world of its own. Taking the ferry from Manhattan easily eliminates so many people. Tourists flock to the usual places like Brooklyn Bridge Park and the Statue of Liberty to get a view with their limited time in New York City. They often overlook Governors Island.

Ready to Propose on Governors Island?

If you're envisioning a romantic, scenic, and unforgettable NYC proposal, Governors Island is a top-tier location that checks every box: stunning views, peaceful vibes, and easy access. As a New York City photographer, I specialize in capturing genuine love stories in iconic and unique locations—and I’d love to help you plan and photograph your perfect proposal.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

Ciaran’s Breathtaking Proposal on Outlook Hill, Governors Island: A Hidden Gem with Iconic Views

Outlook Hill: A Proposal Spot Like No Other

When it came time for Ciaran to propose, he knew he wanted a setting that felt unique, meaningful, and visually unforgettable. He found it on Outlook Hill, the highest point on Governors Island—a rising green oasis with sweeping, cinematic views of the New York Harbor, the Statue of Liberty, and the Manhattan skyline.

Ciaran’s proposal on Outlook Hill was a perfect blend of natural beauty, quiet intimacy, and iconic NYC charm. The views made it grand; the setting made it serene. For couples seeking a proposal location that’s both accessible and extraordinary, Governors Island offers a truly one-of-a-kind experience.

Why Governors Island Is a Hidden Gem for Proposals

While Central Park and Brooklyn Bridge Park often steal the spotlight, Governors Island is one of NYC’s most underrated yet unforgettable destinations for romantic moments, especially proposals. Just a short ferry ride from Lower Manhattan, the island offers the feel of a serene getaway without ever leaving the city.

Free from cars and crowded streets, Governors Island is peaceful, spacious, and rich with natural beauty and panoramic views. It feels like a world apart—making it the perfect place to escape the noise and focus on what really matters.

Outlook Hill: A Proposal Spot Like No Other

Outlook Hill is one of the island’s highest vantage points, offering 360-degree views that are truly unmatched. As Ciaran and his partner climbed the winding path to the top, they were surrounded by native plantings, open sky, and gentle harbor breezes. Once at the summit, they were met with a stunning view that included:

• The Statue of Liberty, standing proudly just across the water

• The Lower Manhattan skyline, with its shimmering towers and iconic architecture

• Expansive views of the New York Harbor, offering a peaceful, open-air atmosphere that’s rare in the city

Thinking of Proposing in New York City?

Skip the crowds and discover one of the city’s most scenic secrets. With unmatched views of the skyline, Statue of Liberty, and beyond, Governors Island is an ideal spot for a romantic, unforgettable proposal—just a short ferry ride away.

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of Professional New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer

Jeremy's Surprise Engagement atop Outlook Hill on Governors Island

Photographing a surprise proposal on Governors Island is memorable experience Unlike many parts of Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Long Island city where there are tourists everywhere, Governors Island is quiet. Why? Because a ferry is the only way to get to Governors Island and that keeps people away. The views on the island are well worth a quick ferry ride, especially if this is where you are going to propose.

Here are a few tips to make sure your secret NYC marriage proposal on Governors Island is captured perfectly by your professional photographer or friend:

1. Plan ahead: Work with a professional proposal photographer to iron out of the the logistics of the proposal in advance. This includes deciding on the exact location, time of day, ferry times, and any special requests or details you would like captured.

2. Be discreet: It's important to blend in. We are just another tourists admiring the sites of NYC!

3. Capture the emotion: The moment is way more than just a photo of someone on their knee.

4. Have fun: Engagements are a happy and exciting occasion, so don't forget to enjoy the moment

Jonathan Heisler Photography is comprised of New York City photographers specializing in photographing private NYC proposals, as well as engagement sessions and weddings.

learn more about hiring a proposal photographer